Home > Site Issues > Contesting unfair/inaccurate ratings?
Contesting unfair/inaccurate ratings?Now, I'm not one to sneeze on critique that's offered to me. I've gotten many bad ratings on my stories before, and I've learned to take it in stride, accept the criticism, and learn from it all. However, there's one particular case where I feel I was rated unfairly.
In this case, it's regarding one of my original horror stories. The characters and the storyline are both mine, and it's archived under Original Fiction/Horror here on FicWad. I emphasize this because, when I logged in today, I saw that it has a negative rating: someone rated it as being OOC.
Now, seeing that the story is quite obviously an original one, I'm having trouble imagining how it is that my characters in my story could be out of character, and what comparison the rater used to make that determination. I'm guessing that someone just mistook it for fanfiction, and rated it as such. The problem being that it isn't fanfiction, and the OOC rating therefore shouldn't apply.
Unfortunately, there's no way that I know of for actually contesting such a thing, so for now, my story is rated as having not portrayed my original characters in-character. So what does one do when one receives a negative rating that doesn't even apply to one's story? Am I going to have to suck it up, or is there a way of contesting such a rating? I can understand where such an allowance would open a huge can of worms, but I also don't think it's fair for authors to receive such ratings. At that point, it's not even critique.
|Ithilwen|| The person's finger probably slipped. It's happened to me a time or two.|
No, ficwad doesn't have a system for appealing WTF ratings, but there is something that you can do:
You can make a post like this one somewhere on the forums, which will cause people to visit your story, metarate the heck out of your ridiculous rating, and perhaps give you some others that might be more appropriate.
|itainohime|| That's always a possibility, too. I highly doubted that it was maliciously done.|
LOL. I'll keep that in mind for next time, should it happen again. XD
|Rous||Another possibility is that someone is trolling and just rating things down. That happened to me and a few others a while back. The only think I can suggest is that you pray that the smarter readers set their filter at -1, because they know this kind of thing happens. If they do not, they they are naive and probably would not understand the story anyway.|
|Ithilwen|| Actually, even -1 'fics show up on an author page, regardless of how the filter is set.|
That being said, it's "One of Those Things," right?
(seven minutes later) Holy crud in a HAT.
|Rous||Went to read the story. Wow! What was the rater thinking? The only way this could be an OCC is for it to be the rater himself. LOL Go, read the review. It says it all. mutters about idiots and ignoramouses|
|Neptune||Hey, I know that story! I read it earlier and never did review (things came up). It's really good. =D|
|PikaBot|| Maybe...the person thought it was out of character for a 9/11 operator to talk like that?|
I dunno, it doesn't make sense, but I can at least get into the head of someone thinking like that.
There was much more to 'The Epilogue' than was shown in Book 7.
In: Harry Potter
- Authors: 276726
- Stories: 39854
Nothing to do with MCR. Just needed a category to put this in.
Fourth one of my series, "Ghost Doll." Anna's past nightmares come back to haunt her out of the blue...
In: Yami no Matsuei
Fifteenth book in "Ghost Doll." One confession in San Diego, California from Anna's aunt, Allison, w...
In: Yami no Matsuei
I'll probably never send it but I want to show people that they're not alone. If anyone wants to tal...
A story of two neko boys in college in a world where most nekos were pets. All the while attempting...