Review for All Those Fscking Happy Endings
All Those Fscking Happy Endings
(#) Beca_nk 2006-08-05 01:51:50 PM
Stumbled across this fic completely by accident, read it, liked it, then realized I'd already read your "How to Commit Seppuku in Three Easy Steps" from a rec. in Maldoror's lj, and I liked that too. So... I figured that deserved a review. :)
You said that you wrote this in one sitting, which rather surprises me. Most one-sitting stories tend to be more unbalanced than this. While we do get more exposition in the front-half, it doesn't trail off into single sentence paragraphs by the end (except for effect, of course--and the effect is nice!).
I particularly liked the bit where Iruka is sneaking a peak at Kakashi's files. Definitely the sign of an unhealthy relationship! Personally, I'm a fan of KakaIru, but I can see how it could all-too-easily end like this.
What I didn't like was the tense-shift in the closing paragraphs. Oh, I can see why you did it--it leaves us hanging, makes the "waiting feeling" that Iruka describes tangible to the reader as well. But it threw me out of the fic.
That said, I rather enjoyed this little piece and thought it could use some review-love. :)
You said that you wrote this in one sitting, which rather surprises me. Most one-sitting stories tend to be more unbalanced than this. While we do get more exposition in the front-half, it doesn't trail off into single sentence paragraphs by the end (except for effect, of course--and the effect is nice!).
I particularly liked the bit where Iruka is sneaking a peak at Kakashi's files. Definitely the sign of an unhealthy relationship! Personally, I'm a fan of KakaIru, but I can see how it could all-too-easily end like this.
What I didn't like was the tense-shift in the closing paragraphs. Oh, I can see why you did it--it leaves us hanging, makes the "waiting feeling" that Iruka describes tangible to the reader as well. But it threw me out of the fic.
That said, I rather enjoyed this little piece and thought it could use some review-love. :)
Author's response
Thank you very much! And... I was recced by MALDOROR? O___O Is there any chance I could get you to point me to this? Holy crap... stunned
Heh, I write all my stories in one sitting, though not normally working under a deadline the way this one was. But if my stuff doesn't get finished all at once it generally doesn't get finished at all, so. ^_^;
The tense-shifting is something I debated about at the time, but in the end it comes down to the fact that the rest of the story is in the past, just leading up to/detailing the events that take place in the present, and it just didn't read right to me without the use of present tense to demonstrate that shift. Sorry it didn't work for you. But glad the rest generally did! Thanks again!
Heh, I write all my stories in one sitting, though not normally working under a deadline the way this one was. But if my stuff doesn't get finished all at once it generally doesn't get finished at all, so. ^_^;
The tense-shifting is something I debated about at the time, but in the end it comes down to the fact that the rest of the story is in the past, just leading up to/detailing the events that take place in the present, and it just didn't read right to me without the use of present tense to demonstrate that shift. Sorry it didn't work for you. But glad the rest generally did! Thanks again!
Filter
You won't see stories with a lower score when you browse or search. Log in to adjust filter.
0
Greed
Featured Story
-
Addict For Dramatics
by MMMramen (PG-13)Lola and Pete have a past together, a past that she is more than willing to forget. Will history rep...
In: Fall Out Boy
Site Stats
- Authors: 89504
- Stories: 25610
Recent Stories
-
The Gate
by Swimming4Life (PG-13)I thought it was only a british TV series, But then he showed up, and my life? I declared it over, a...
In: Doctor Who
-
The Vampire Fanatics!
by MyChemicalFangirl (G)Gee starts up a vampire fanclub. Mabye frerard later.. MCR,FOB,PATD,A7X,TH,GD. Read it. XD
-
If I Should Die Before I Wake
by mysilentromance (PG-13)Frank prayed, "If I should die before I wake, it shall be the Lord I thank"
-
In The Centre Of A Restaurant
by TheGiinger (G)When one girls gets disowned for a concert and one is lonely, add MCR and see what happens!
-
Fuck The School [*Frerard*]
by lollykillerx_x (G)"Hm,… Tall guy with the perfect black hair?” I asked they both turned to me. “Me… ?”