Review for Dumbledore's Final Trick

Dumbledore's Final Trick

(#) haldriel 2011-02-03

It is a very interesting story, with an original idea.

I like it very much and I hope that you enjoyed to write your story as I enjoyed to read it

Only a mistake : The philosopher Stone was really a test, it was said,implied in fact, during one of Snape's memories of HP and the Deathly Hallows.

Sorry for the poor English, I'm French.

Author's response

Do not worry, your English is better than many people's. Merci bien for your review. I feel I must disagree with you about the Stone - Harry suspected it might be a test in the first book, but in Snape's memories, Dumbledore says nothing about the Stone - he only says much later that it was necessary to try Harry's strength. I don't think there's enough obvious one way or the other what Dumbledore really planned.