Categories > Books > Harry Potter
Frightful magic
3 reviewsHarry potter was killed at the tender age of 3, but insted of going to Heaven like his mothers blessing wanted, or hell like the forcee of the killing curse...he went to Halloween town. there he be...
1Original
Reviews
Frightful magic
(#) kimr 2009-09-01
An interesting premise, done badly, very hard to follow the story also the formatting leaves something to be desired, you really need to add some back story maybe in the form of a prologue, as at the moment it seems to be a disjointed mess.
Frightful magic
(#) falcon_phoenix 2009-09-01
Kimr has it right. It is interesting, and orignal.
But you really need to separate the paragraphs so that people can actually READ the mess.
also, and these are just a few of the mistakes, its Minerva, not mirvina or miverna. its aforementioned, not fore mentioned.
If you want to continue writing, get a beta. soon.
But beyond the numerous mistakes, it was interesting, but it does need some back-story.Frightful magic
(#) Ashestoashes 2009-09-06
I agree on the spelling and formatting issue. Also, I don't like your Sirius, Remus and Snape and fear the role they are going to play.
I don't agree on the prologue issue. It's perfectly possible to start a story like this.
But you'll have to come with a very good explanation for Jack being/seeming to be Harry. Halloween is quite old, ergo Jack is quite old (hmm, except perhaps if you played the games it seems if I read it right on Wikipedia, but whatever). And what with Sally, is she for some reason Luna then? Otherwise it is quite original and if you think about it, not that far-fetched. But only when Harry is the adopted son of Jack and Sally when Jack came by the house of the Potters on Halloween when they died and took Harry away, which explains the "we found him" too.
Sign up to review this story.