Categories > Books > Lord of the Rings
Gandalf's No Good, Rotten, Really Bad Day
6 reviewsA few things go wrong at the Prancing Pony, and Gandalf has to explain to Manwe how it all happened. AU bookverse. 2006 MEFAward WINNER--FIRST PLACE--BEST PARODY
5Funny
Reviews
Gandalf's No Good, Rotten, Really Bad Day
(#) Ithilwen 2006-08-26
This would be funnier if it were clearer from the beginning whether or not it directly follows book events.Author's response
Hello, Ithilwen
Thanks for your review. The problem with your criticism is that the story both does and does not follow book events. Granted, you do need a good knowledge of book canon to get the point of the joke, but I think that is generally true of all good parody.
G.A.Gandalf's No Good, Rotten, Really Bad Day
(#) HRT 2006-08-28
Just wonderful humor. The reader does need a good knowledge of book-based canon to enjoy this, but that's the glory of Tolkien. The comic timing in this piece is absolutely perfect! I highly recommend this story to all readers.Author's response
Thanks, HRT! I'm always happy to bring laughter to a new reader. I felt positively evil killing off Aragorn (especially since he's my favorite character), but that's part of the sheer joy of irreverence! I hope you read more of my stories
G.A.Gandalf's No Good, Rotten, Really Bad Day
(#) kira_k 2007-08-24
I enjoyed this, very good work! :D Poor Aragorn...!
By the way, it might be only my character coding but Manwe's name looks screwed up (the accented e to be specific.)Author's response
thanks for the tip--I'm fixing it.
G.A.
thanks for the tip--I'm fixing it.
G.A.Gandalf's No Good, Rotten, Really Bad Day
(#) Gabi4CSI 2008-10-23
Gotta love parody! A very nice little twist on what could have happened had evrything gone wrong in Bree. I was particularly amused by the calling Gandalf a dimwit :)
I've just finished re watching and reading LOTR, So this was a nice break after the double sadness of watching and reading the end!
I'm currently working on an LOTR piece, sort of a cross between the original, and this show Lost in Austen (ok, not a cross, I used the idea is more accurate!)
Loved the story, hope to read more of your work
xx
Sign up to review this story.