Review for Like Some Song You Can't Unlearn

Like Some Song You Can't Unlearn

(#) Alorkin 2009-01-22

Well done! Harry has successfully talked Ginny away from using the diary, without violence, but with an unexpected dividend. Ginny gets to destroy the horcrux. Definitely some personal satisfaction there!

I suspect Slughorne is going to be wetting himself in excitement if he ever learns of the indescribably valuable potions ingredients just waiting to be harvested in the chamber.

Oopsey! Harry forgot a little something. "Erm, sorry, Luna. I'm an arse."

Why is Poppy so incensed? Harry's note explained the boggart, she should understand that fear muse be faced. Harry's statement to Dumbledore seems to support this conclusion.

Sooner or later, Harry is going to have to tell Dumbles about the great honkin' snake in the basement.

Another fine chapter. I fear this story is nearing it's conclusion, but i will stay with you for as long as it takes.

Alorkin

Author's response

Why on earth would I want to involve Slughorn in this story? What possible use would Hogwarts and Harry have for an experienced and qualified Potions Master, not to mention someone to head Slytherin House. They have Snivellus for that... Hmm, have you been reading my notes?

Poppy is incensed for the same reason most people don't like Harry: she sees him as a murderer and sexual despot. He killed a man in cold blood, the fact that he deserved it is irrelevant, and is bedding the widow, now he is dealing with children and dozens of them have been cursed while she was helpless to cure them.

And the story is about half done. Thanks for the review.

BJH