"Something about this seems so familiar that I'm now having a hard time reconciling the idea that a Marauder would sign up with Riddle. Death-Eater just seems to scream anti-humor, and these guys knew how to have fun"
Nice logic, but Peter Pettigrew was a Marauder as well.
Author's response
Something I'm striving for is to make sure that Holly is as believably wrong as she is believably right. Without hearing much about the specific character of each Marauder, her logic stands up (I hope).
wh