OH OH OH OH OH!!!
Sorry, but, dude! You should totally do a Blood Brothers or Johnny Whitney song. Johnny's got a really high voice.
BUT!
A couple by the Blood Brothers are:
"Devastator"
"The Shame"
"Camouflage, Camouflage" (you'd probably need two people to sing this one)
"Peacock Skeleton with Crooked Feathers"
"Burn, Piano Island, Burn!"
By Whitney:
"Blinding Rage"
"Billboard Supermodel"
BY JAGUAR LOVEEEEEEEEEEEE:
"Sad Parade" (You can't hear it online, cause it's SUPER indie...I could email it to you if you want. It's totally worth it. Really pretty tune. Email's: comecrashingdown@live.com if you're interested)
"Georgia"
NEON BLONDE:
"Savannah Nights" (I can't find the lyrics, though...)
"Headlines"
"Chandeliers & Vines"
"Wings Made Out Of Noise"
^^^ Those were all Johnny Whitney related because he has an awesomely high voice.
Uhm, how about The Shins?
"Simple Song"
"New Slang"
"Port of Morrow"
"Kissing the Lipless"
"Saint Simon"
Grant Lee Buffalo is awesome too:
"Mockingbirds"
"Fuzzy"
"Honey, Don't Think"
"Hook"
Jeff Buckley, of course:
"Grace"
"Lilac Wine"
"Calling You" (his cover, but really amazing"
I can't think of many more at the moment......lemme know how it plays out. You could always cover "Northern Downpour" cause it is a fucking amazing song. But, really, Lilac Wine is really beautiful. You could probably pull it off!
Good luck, dude!
Author's response
Thanks so much for the feedback! Gah, your taste in music is PERF. I mean REALLY. Asdfghjkl. Thanks for all the help c: And yes, Northern Downpour is ALWAYS a viable choice. c: