Categories > Games > Sonic the Hedgehog > Should’ve when you could’ve

Should’ve when you could’ve

by Crimsonroselee 0 reviews

Sonic finally decides to ask Amy out… then finds out she's dating Shadow. Will they get back together or has Sonic lost Amy forever? not connected to SonAmy family.

Category: Sonic the Hedgehog - Rating: PG - Genres: Humor - Characters: Amy Rose,Sonic - Warnings: [?] - Published: 2025-05-18 - 454 words - Complete

0Unrated
Sonic raced to the door and knocked. His heart was pounding as he waited on Amy to open the door.



He had finally worked up the nerve to ask Amy out on a date.



Amy, all dressed up in a new black dress, answered the door. "Oh, Sonic, I wasn't expecting you."



"I wasn't expecting you to be all ready to go." Sonic replied. "I came here to ask if you wanted to go to dinner at that new fancy French restaurant that just opened up on the edge of town."



"Oh, this is awkward." Amy said, fidgeting with her purse strap.



Sonic tensed up. "Why? Are you going out with Tails?"



"No, I'm actually going out with Shadow." Amy replied.



"Him?" Sonic asked. "After he beat the daylights out of us? You're actually gonna go out with that jerk?"



Amy nodded. "He's been getting help," She said. "Poor guy had an awful life. Anyway, he's a really nice guy once you get to know him."



Sonic nodded tersely.



"It's not going to affect the team, is it?" Amy asked.



"Why?" Sonic asked.



"I'll quit if it bothers you." Amy replied. "I had hoped we could stay friends, but I'll understand if you can't do that."



"No, don't quit." Sonic said. "I- I'm happy for you, Ames."



"Thanks, Sonic." Amy replied.



Sonic grinned weakly. "Have fun." He said. He raced off.
**

Days had gone by since Sonic's disastrous attempt to ask Amy out.



Sonic could barely pretend he was happy for Amy, but she didn't seem to notice.





Then again, how could she? She was more focused on her relationship than anything else.



Sonic folded his arms and gritted his teeth as Shadow and Amy walked down the beach while holding hands. "That jerk." He sneered. "What does she see in that guy?"



Tails sat down beside Sonic and patted his back.



Sonic huffed and got up. "That's it." He said, storming off.



Tails flinched. "What?"



"I'm leaving the island before I see her pushing a stroller full of his babies around." Sonic said. He climbed into the Blue Force One. "I'm going to live with my brother on-"



Tails stared wide-eyed at Sonic. "Your brother?" He asked. "You have a brother?"



"Yeah and a sister." Sonic replied. "Manic would be easier to live with than Sonia, if he's not in prison."



"Prison?" Tails asked.



"He's a kleptomaniac." Sonic replied. "Anyway, I'll call you when I get there."



Tails furrowed his brow. "I… okay." He said, shrugging. "Is this why I had to make mystery gifts before?"



"Yeah, Manic loves the hoverboard by the way." Sonic replied. He started the Blue Force One. "See you."



Tails waved weakly. "G'bye, big bro." He said sadly.
Sign up to rate and review this story