Categories > Books > Harry Potter > Triwizard Redux
Yule
20 reviewsWhen would be the best point in time for an over-powered Harry to return to his past? Right before the First Task! In this chapter, Yule.
5Original
Reviews
Triwizard Redux
(#) jbstarnes1 2006-11-01
Though it doesn't have as much to do with this chapter there is a common current - in this work and your other HP fics - about the supposed backwardness of England and Europe in its social systems (particularly politics, race- and classism, and celebrity worship/demonization) versus the rest of the world, particularly North America and Australia; a point of view that seems to miss the point of those particular themes and the way they're presented in the first place.
The way the wizards behave in England and Europe is pretty much the way people behave everywhere. It's not tradition or social mores making them act that way, it's human nature, and that's not going to change just by flying across an ocean. Suggesting otherwise seems more than a little disingenious.Triwizard Redux
(#) matthiasblack 2006-11-01
Just what the doctor ordered, a new chapter to a great fic. I am excited about the upcoming task and interested in what you do with little Gabrielle in the lake. Good luck with the fic.Triwizard Redux
(#) TheIllusiveOne 2006-11-01
I usually enjoy your work, but there is just way too much fluff in this for me to stomach. Get back to the plot line and quit the corny dialogue, man!Author's response
sorry, but I like fluff, esp. in Christmas chapters.
"T"Triwizard Redux
(#) Anaknisatanas 2006-11-02
I love this story! Harry is so cool. I love powerful Harry, but just so long as he's not too powerful. I also like how you've made him intelligent and that he's with Hermione. The bit with Draco scoffing about her jewlery was priceless! And I also like how Harry interacts with Cedric and Snape. I hope you have an update planned for the next week.Triwizard Redux
(#) rhynim 2006-11-02
i have to admit you have a good story going here
good luck and keep on itTriwizard Redux
(#) brad 2006-11-04
Nice little Luna bits in this - her getting along better with her housemates, and her making the 'dream catcher' for Harry.
Yes, my question about the level of intimacy between Harry and Hermione was certainly answered in this chapter, as well as your response to my last review!! I'm a little squicked by how young the kids are in this; Hermione barely 15, Harry 14, yes? Oh well, you've never had them shy in any of your stories, although in many of them they're just a year or two older.Triwizard Redux
(#) GrantLarceny 2016-08-06
The Snape rehab is BS. People as old as Snape don't change. Get a clue Dumbledore!!Triwizard Redux
(#) Noylj 2023-08-24
When has talking to Bumbles ever done any good? When has talking to any adult magical ever done any good.
How did Harry get the cup (I think you had him say he retrieved it)?
Sign up to review this story.