FicWad

Categories > Anime/Manga > Full Metal Alchemist > The Water Stone of the Wise

Reviews

• The Water Stone of the Wise

  (#) ancalyme 2005-09-18

  This story is really original - I like it. I haven't seen the movie, so I'm unclear on a few details (though I do know the general content) - I can't give you appropiate critique. From what I've seen of the end of series, Ed is pleasantly IC and the OCs aren't glaring. The Philosopher's Stone is a nice touch.

• The Water Stone of the Wise

  (#) Loise 2005-10-04

  I enjoyed this immensely. Through I am hitting myself over the head for not getting the Jones reference.
  
  The plot was built up slowly so you got to appreciate the fullness of what was going to happen.

• The Water Stone of the Wise

  (#) ihatemona 2006-01-07

  To my greatest shame, I think I saw your recent post on LJ and made a disgusted face of doom and didn't bother clicking on the link to what I now realize was this piece of fanfiction. I don't really know how I came to this site and found this fic, but I think that overlooking your post was one of the hughest mistakes I've made since I entered the FMA fandom TT_TT
  
  Not only did you keep Ed incredibly in-character, but also the story is original, captivating, and damn if it is not on first-class crack! I love it. Love it like there is no tomorow! humps the fic
  
  Oh Ed is so priceless; looking for a fight even in his 'condition' is oh so like him XD
  
  Really, really love this fic. re-reads Is there more to it?

• The Water Stone of the Wise

  (#) albapuella 2006-01-16

  Wow. This is a combination that I wouldn't have thought of but it seems to work out pretty well. I'm just not sure whether this is supposed to be a one shot or if you plan on adding more to it - I hope it's the latter :)

• The Water Stone of the Wise

  (#) Heathenesque 2006-01-19

  falls over OMG! That is brilliant! I can hardly wait for the rest of this wonderful adventure to continue! I never suspected a crossover until the end, but it all came to gether beautifully, and makes so much sense.

• The Water Stone of the Wise

  (#) Pata-Hikari 2006-08-03

  Ok.
  
  This wins for coolest crossover ever. XD
  
  Really unique and very fun sounding.

• The Water Stone of the Wise

  (#) Ross_the_Boss 2008-05-14

  Very interesting cross-over.. I can clearly see those two together.

• The Water Stone of the Wise

  (#) enuy 2008-05-30

  This is the best FMA crossover idea. Ed ranting at birds was priceless. I hope you will continue it.

• The Water Stone of the Wise

  (#) tanteikun 2009-05-06

  im very interested in seeing how this pans out. please write more!

Sign up to review this story.