Review for Shattered Idols

Shattered Idols

(#) stealacandy 2007-10-22

Hey, this is not fair!

I thought Harry was dead, gone for good - will stay dead.

Coming back to life is stupid, and takes away from your story.

Granted, JKR did just that, but it's still stupid - as is JKR herself.

You should put a warning in the summary that this story is a DH-trap missing moment, and warn away all those who can't stand that rag.

mo

Author's response

I appreciate the fact you took the time to review but I can't help but feel that you missed the point of the story.

It was meant to be a rant from Ginny post-war/post-7th book. It had little to do with Harry and more to do with Ginny's reflection on his actions.

I didn't mean to make it sound like he died and stayed dead, but if you read the entire descrpition it does in a way mention that he is still alive.

thanks for your time -PINKhairedLOVER