FicWad

Categories > Books > Harry Potter > Harry Potter and YASMWTS

Reviews

• Harry Potter and YASMWTS

  (#) dennisud 2008-12-22

  Still gets squiggly with this concepts... but its working well so far. Wonder who's kids will be there to be their friends and antagonists at Hogwarts!
  
  BTW what will happen when Luna and Padma succeed?
  
  dennisud

  Author's response

  - Well, since it's only been 5 years since the war, I'm not planning on many familiar names to Hogwarts... Maybe toward their 6th or 7th year...
  
  - Luna and Padma aren't going to succeed.

• Harry Potter and YASMWTS

  (#) whatareyouevensaying 2008-12-22

  Very interesting update. I really like how well all of the adults are taking things, and I'm especially glad that Padma is no longer completely isolated. Luna will be good for her.
  
  Looking forward to more.

• Harry Potter and YASMWTS

  (#) whatareyouevensaying 2008-12-22

  Very interesting update. I really like how well all of the adults are taking things, and I'm especially glad that Padma is no longer completely isolated. Luna will be good for her.
  
  Looking forward to more.

  Author's response

  - Well, as I see it, part of adulthood is dealing with reality as best you can...
  
  - Luna and Padma have been busy the last five years, and they've made some progress... And reveal the bad news to Hermione next chapter.

• Harry Potter and YASMWTS

  (#) whatareyouevensaying 2008-12-22

  Very interesting update. I really like how well all of the adults are taking things, and I'm especially glad that Padma is no longer completely isolated. Luna will be good for her.
  
  Looking forward to more.

• Harry Potter and YASMWTS

  (#) axelrajr 2008-12-22

  very interesting fic.
  
  i would like to know what luna and padme are doing though.
  
  i think given a choice though, harry might reject the chance to be restored if it meant losing tom.

• Harry Potter and YASMWTS

  (#) DrT 2008-12-22

  Rough day working with this site. I forget all my compliments from other attempts to review, so I'll just say 'good chapter' and wonder if people still think Hermione is the birth mum

• Harry Potter and YASMWTS

  (#) DrT 2008-12-22

  5th try, fingers tired; there are times I hate this site, like today, as my last chapter is in limbo.
  
  I didn't expect this to be more than one chapter, and I liked this one a great deal. Thanks for the surprise. Do folks still think Hermione is the birth mum?

  Author's response

  - I know what you mean. Ficwad is odd today, it took me most of an hour to get the chapter to load.
  
  - Some do suspect her motherhood is more than adopted, yes. The timing does seem odd given the rumors swirling about 4th year don't it. (I never planned it that way either, it just came to me when I was writing the Augusta scene...)

• Harry Potter and YASMWTS

  (#) jjracer24 2008-12-22

  Good stuff, I'm glad you decided to add another chapter. Especially liked the sorting and the revelation that Hermione was supposed to be in Ravenclaw, not that that was a big surprise. Keep up the good work.

• Harry Potter and YASMWTS

  (#) dennisud 2008-12-22

  I wonder if instead of Luna & Padma don't succeed Would they be able to redo the same spell to maybe shrink Padma to their ages maybe during their Hogwarts years?
  
  Just a mental burp for you to ponder.
  
  ;-)

• Harry Potter and YASMWTS

  (#) dennisud 2008-12-22

  I wonder if instead of Luna & Padma don't succeed Would they be able to redo the same spell to maybe shrink Padma to their ages maybe during their Hogwarts years?
  
  Just a mental burp for you to ponder.
  
  ;-)

Sign up to review this story.