FicWad

Categories > Books > Harry Potter > ~Harry Potter: The Silent Halls Of Hogwarts~

Reviews

• ~Harry Potter: The Silent Halls Of Hogwarts~

  (#) anonmg1 2007-09-01

  Thanks very much for the re-post. This version didn't cause a translation headache. Can you give an estimate for when to expect the next one?
  
  P.S: As it is now about 2:30 AM, I'll try to re-review with appropriately articulated sympathies and chapter 6 & 7 comments some time this afternoon or evening. Right now, though, I need sleep.

  Author's response

  You're welcome. I'd actually had the chapter ready and was waiting for the maintenance to get done, and I posted it almost immediately, so I fuess not all of the bugs were worked out on the site, and the formatting was completely messed up.
  
  Next one should be out this weekend - I've transcribed it from Taylor's notebook to a Word document, and right now it's been sent off to my beta, so I expect to get it back today or tomorrow.

• ~Harry Potter: The Silent Halls Of Hogwarts~

  (#) Cateagle 2007-09-02

  Now that was an interesting chapter in several ways. I admit to wondering just how the Daily Prophet got their information so fast. I'll also admit to enjoying the encounter/confrontation with Draco and I have to wonder if that attitude might affect how Ron and company view Harry. The Wizard's Duel should be interesting, esp. if Harry finds ways of coping that Draco can't handle. ALl in all, a very good chapter.

  Author's response

  
  Glad you liked it. About the Daily Prophet, more will be revealed on that later in the year. Glad you enjoyed the Draco encounter, and yes, the Wizard's duel will be quite interesting.
  
  Thanks for taking the time to review.

• ~Harry Potter: The Silent Halls Of Hogwarts~

  (#) whatareyouevensaying 2007-09-02

  Great update! I feel pretty bad for Harry at this point, stuck fighting a fairly experienced wizard on his...second day? Well, at least he proved the Sorting Hat right.
  
  As for DH...I agree with you in terms of everything you said about Harry and Hermione. The only thing that I really couldn't stand was pretty much every time Snape's name was mentioned, particularly the memories. I could really do without those, especially since an alarming number of fanfictions are adapting them in.

  Author's response

  Great update! I feel pretty bad for Harry at this point, stuck fighting a fairly experienced wizard on his...second day? Well, at least he proved the Sorting Hat right.
  
  As for DH...I agree with you in terms of everything you said about Harry and Hermione. The only thing that I really couldn't stand was pretty much every time Snape's name was mentioned, particularly the memories. I could really do without those, especially since an alarming number of fanfictions are adapting them in.
  
  Yep, it'll be a rather interestingduel, especially since Malfoy has several years on him already.
  
  And yes, I also couldn't really stand the Snape stuff. In this story, he'll be the usual git, and I don't plan on incorporating that part of DH into this story.
  
  
  Yep, it'll be a rather interestingduel, especially since Malfoy has several years on him already.
  
  And yes, I also couldn't really stand the Snape stuff. In this story, he'll be the usual git, and I don't plan on incorporating that part of DH into this story.

• ~Harry Potter: The Silent Halls Of Hogwarts~

  (#) anniejay 2007-09-05

  Your friend would be delighted with the way you continued. I like the way you have kept the street child in Harry he would not change overnight

• ~Harry Potter: The Silent Halls Of Hogwarts~

  (#) TxA_GunFighter 2007-09-09

  Very good chapter. I really like Hermione, Susan, And everyone has to love Luna. Wouldn't mind it if Harry ended up with all three.
  
  gunny

Sign up to review this story.