FicWad

Categories > Books > Harry Potter > Luna's Hubby

Reviews

• Luna's Hubby

  (#) DrT 2007-09-08

  Excellent chapter! I'm surprised Harry reacted quite that badly, but it was within the realm of reason
  
  "T"

• Luna's Hubby

  (#) Alorkin 2007-09-08

  Harry is being an ass. Of course, he is thirteen.
  
  Mike's taking Harry to church with him was a really good idea. The passage from the New Testament was particularly appropriate. Harry needed to see that he was being unnecessarily cruel to Luna. As he said, it was a prank they both would have enjoyed, had the circumstances been different.
  
  A wonderful twist. I've read a few where the dragon willingly allows Harry to take the egg, but this is the first where she refuses (out of a sense of duty/pride) Harry's using the avis spell is also unusual.
  
  As always, I eagerly await the next chapter of 'Luna's Hubby'. Alorkin

• Luna's Hubby

  (#) whatareyouevensaying 2007-09-10

  Great chapter, I really enjoyed Harry's temporary panic. Very realistic. Dunno how I feel about using church as a plot device, but then again, it might only seem that way because I'm an atheist. Either way, I loved it, and I'm looking forward to the next one.

• Luna's Hubby

  (#) BloodyTalons 2007-09-24

  Actually, I disagree with these other reviews. I think Harry not only acted appropriately in his anger; I think it was wrong for him to have to apologize. Luna disregarded his safety and risked exposing his true identity all so that she could satisfy her curiosity and to play a prank (something they haven't really shown a habit of doing).
  
  Luna has heard all the horror stories about the tournament. She knows they are to keep Harry's true identity secret as well as the secret about their bond. So, entering him into a tournament where his life is in danger and where his life will be scrutinized by the press is not showing any consideration on her part.
  
  Harry has every right to be angry and every right to break their bond since she place so little importance on him. She only thought of herself in doing what she did.

  Author's response

  Harry had every right to be angry, but he didn't have the right to cruel to Luna (just as she didn't have the right to endanger him). So they both had to apologize to each other.
  
  Thanks for the comments.
  
  Tom A.

Sign up to review this story.