FicWad

Categories > Books > Harry Potter > The Face in the Pool

Reviews

• The Face in the Pool

  (#) Bronze 2015-12-23

  I read this once before and have now enjoyed it twice. I feel this is how Dumb-Dumb should be treated if not out right killed shortly before he could place Harry with the Dursleys. Harsh you say? Compared to what Harry needlessly went through, IS IT TRULY HARSH ENOUGH? And let us not forget the very real possibility that it was Dumb-Dumbs' actions that made Harry an orphan in the first place. In almost all fan fiction I read Dumb-Dumb placed the charm to hide both families and therefore also knew who the secret keeper was. Thus he knew Sirius was innocent. So the only reason to keep Sirius in prison was to keep Harry with his abusive relatives. These are some of my reason for not trusting and totally hating the creature know by way too many names and titles.

• The Face in the Pool

  (#) jspring1 2017-04-15

  One of my favorite flicks. I love most of DrT's stories and this is one that I find myself reading at least once per year. :) Thanks for writing.
  

  Author's response

  I'm glad you enjoy it! Thanks

• The Face in the Pool

  (#) Jimbocous 2021-05-06

  As always, thanks for a great read. Nicely written.

  Author's response

  glad you enjoyed my old story; thanks!

• The Face in the Pool

  (#) Noylj 2022-05-30

  Wish the story was longer and Bumble's was broken (and Snape was turned into fertilizer).

Sign up to review this story.