Categories > Books > Harry Potter
Granger Who
17 reviewsHave you ever realized that all you know about Hermione is what she said about herself and what she did in front of others? And that the trio is much too lucky for it to be natural?
5Original
Reviews
Granger Who
(#) thomaswatts 2009-01-29
Interesting start. I have only one complaint. That Ravenclaw is too omniscience. Even someone who has been around the block dozens of times still only has one view point, their own.
She would not know what TR had been up to, nor would she know what AD had been up to, only themselves would. No one knew about Horcruxes until Harry stumbled into one (the diary).
Very interesting story, but as of the first chapter, completely unbelievable.Granger Who
(#) Vanir 2009-02-01
Intriguing. I guess that after a millennium, one has a fair selection of scrying and eavesdropping spells to fall back on to appear omniscient. Perhaps make a note of it somewhere? Making a MarySue out of Rowena Ravenclaw will earn you viruses in your mailbox. Do "humanise" her, please. I'm looking forward to the rest.
VanirGranger Who
(#) Clell65619 2009-03-12
- Very original, never seen anything like this before. Looking forward to the next offering.Granger Who
(#) am12 2009-03-21
Yeah, interesting. YOu're probably going to be flamed by some for creating "Super!Hermione", but if you continue on like this, you should be okay. She's manipulative. But her motive is shaky and unclear?Granger Who
(#) Nightrunner 2009-04-30
Now this is truly an interesting concept. I'm wondering where you're going to take this, and how far.
It should make for a really fun read!
RobertGranger Who
(#) HallowsNotHorcruxes 2010-02-10
Very unique, and I must say, I love how you had the mental exchange between Hermione/Rowena and the Sorting Hat. The clever way you fit everything in is worthy of Rowena Ravenclaw herself.Granger Who
(#) Brianna_Lee 2021-12-20
I wish you would continue this. It's very clever and adds a bit of mystique to the whole of Harry Potter.
Sign up to review this story.