FicWad

Categories > Books > Harry Potter > Harry Potter and the Lord's Lament

Reviews

• Harry Potter and the Lord's Lament

  (#) Circaea 2011-01-26

  Congratulations on having the nerve to come back to a story over two years after the last update.
  
  I saw in your author's note that you got some discouraging reviews. I'm in the process of writing my first fanfic, and have been surprised at how much reviews affect me. People forget that there's a difference between someone writing for fun, or as a writing exercise, and and maybe just starting out, and someone trying to be a serious or professional writer.
  
  My one piece of advice is to not be afraid to edit your old entries.
  
  As to the story, having just read the whole thing through instead of waiting two years, you will be pleased to know that I didn't notice any sort of jarring break at all between the third and fourth chapters. You just picked up where you left off, which is impressive.

• Harry Potter and the Lord's Lament

  (#) Vanir 2011-01-26

  What Circaea said.
  
  It's been a while so i reread it and treated it as a new aquaintance. I stand by my previous (and rather bland) reviews.
  
  
  I thoroughly enjoyed this story. This magical world seems a bit more modern than most, and the eloquence is wonderful. While I'm of course curious about the storyline, i also look forward to the next installment just for the language.
  
  I really enjoyed the unstated dinner. There's no need for a blow-by-blow, and this way, this dinner is a resource for the plotholes that keep opening in the best of stories. They talked about it at dinner. So There!
  
  Flames suck. I've had a few, and it doesn't really help to tell yourself that they don't matter 'cause they do. And not. They are a part of why my Muse took off with a strange bloke in a blue box. One day i will follow your example and finish my story.
  
  I'll be here for the rest.
  
  Vanir

• Harry Potter and the Lord's Lament

  (#) cnorthfield2000 2011-01-26

  I completely agree with Vanir on your story 100%. I may not be able to review every chapter but know that I am reading and following every chapter.
  
  I, too, will be here for the rest.

• Harry Potter and the Lord's Lament

  (#) PGHammer 2011-02-01

  Is that a dragon I see, riding the air-currents, getting ready to open its mouth and burn Dumbles' credibility to a crisp? (His PUBLIC credibility/reputation, that is; his credibility/reputation with Harry and most of the Wizengamot is already roasted.) Percy stops by #12 (with his Penelope); and earlier, Hermione apologizes (to Harry) and gets gently called on the carpet about Wizarding Tradition (also by Harry). And we should also have the answer to the Sixty-Four-Galleon Question as to what that voice in Harry's Head is coming from - his House Potter Ring. (The Voice itself gave the jig up by saying that it has been advising Potters since the 1100s. That is eight centuries, folks; given how long some families in Magical Britain keep other things, what would be MOST likely, other than weapons, to withstand the test of time and be held by magical nobility?) Also, Rings of Nobility (the heraldric term - it's not magical OR muggle) can also be used to affix seals to documents; yes, it's more tradition. That use is straight out of known history (specifically, European history), as this was the case for nobility throughout Europe.

• Harry Potter and the Lord's Lament

  (#) Vanir 2011-05-04

  This has become a story i return to at least weekly. It's just so.. I dont know, mature. The language, the setting, everything. I only wish it was longer.=)
  Ordinarily, the feudal-style wizarding world seems locked in the 1650's. This one is more late 1700's with some 1900´s influences. I verily like. Have a box of [sunshine] and do continue.
  
  Vanir

• Harry Potter and the Lord's Lament

  (#) NobleK 2014-07-13

  Will you for the love of Pete return and finish this?!

• Harry Potter and the Lord's Lament

  (#) Avalone 2015-10-22

  This is awesome! A great story that's very well written. The overall narrative flows very nicely and there are no awkward areas. The characters feel real and are believable. There are no Mary-sues or Gary-stues. The grammar and punctuation is excellent. I especially enjoy how you have fleshed out wizarding society. I hope that you will continue this story and update soon!

• Harry Potter and the Lord's Lament

  (#) the-real-narnia 2016-10-19

  This story is amazing, and I sincerely hope you decide to continue this. I'm very interested in seeing where this is going. :)

Sign up to review this story.