FicWad

Categories > Books > Harry Potter

Reviews

• Epilogue Minus 15

  (#) whatareyouevensaying 2008-06-11

  Very interesting piece(s). I really like how bearable you've made Harry/Ginny. Keep things going like this and I might be able to get on board with YOUR epilogue. Those names...
  
  Looking forward to more of whatever you decide to write.

  Author's response

  Thanks. A "bearable" H/G is a BIG compliment in many circles. As to the names, I still can't imagine a way to make THAT bearable.
  
  BJH

• Epilogue Minus 15

  (#) Cateagle 2008-06-11

  I like it and it's quite plausible. 'Twill be interesting to see what party is behind the restless dementors and what their ultimate game is. The scenes between Harry & Ginny most definitely ring true and the bit about Ron & Hermione and how things settled down between them was a hoot.

• Epilogue Minus 15

  (#) thomaswatts 2008-06-11

  A Harry/Ginny & Hermione/Ron story I can stomach, all involved being canon believable! For that I thank you.
  However, I thought in the Epilogue both Albus and Rose were being sent off for their first year. If so, then Ginny would have given birth first to James. You have Hermione pregnant with child, which could only be Rose who is younger.
  Keep up the great writing.

  Author's response

  That is true, but the canon Epilogue is 19 years after the final fight, this story is 15 years before that or 4 years after the battle. James won't be born for another three years. As for Hermione's child being Rose... Hermione won't be pregnant with her for a couple years yet. The baby she is now carrying would be somewhere between Teddy and Victorie on one end and Rose and James on the other. If it lives that is.
  
  BJH

• Epilogue Minus 15

  (#) stealacandy 2008-06-12

  Good to hear you're alivem BJ.
  
  This one is better than the last, IMO, and I hope you update soon, because you kind of left over a cliffie.
  
  Still, if it comes at the expense of not updating your multi-chapter story, forgot what's it called, it's been that long - well, then, take your time...
  
  
  -mo

• Epilogue Minus 15

  (#) Wolfric 2008-06-13

  I enjoyed the story. It is a plausible part of the puzzle. Thanks for writing. W.

• Epilogue Minus 15

  (#) theform 2008-08-19

  you've turned in another wonderful effort, as usual. i will say that the last scene seemed kind of thrown in there and didn't really connect well with the rest of the story. i'm not saying that the scene, didn't belong there, but i feel that it wasn't up to your usual standards. on a different note, why does harry keep putting himself in situations where he gets derided by his superiors? that he would allow dawlish to give him a dress down seems incomprehensible. he destroyed voldemort without the ministry so why would he join the ministry? simply because shacklebolt is in charge? seems flimsy to me. other than that, i really enjoyed what you've done filling the gap. you've honestly rescued the ending of book seven for me. and for that, i'm grateful. not that this a regular story, but are you going to keep filling in the space between the end and epilogue?
  

• Epilogue Minus 15

  (#) theform 2008-08-19

  you've turned in another wonderful effort, as usual. i will say that the last scene seemed kind of thrown in there and didn't really connect well with the rest of the story. i'm not saying that the scene, didn't belong there, but i feel that it wasn't up to your usual standards. on a different note, why does harry keep putting himself in situations where he gets derided by his superiors? that he would allow dawlish to give him a dress down seems incomprehensible. he destroyed voldemort without the ministry so why would he join the ministry? simply because shacklebolt is in charge? seems flimsy to me. other than that, i really enjoyed what you've done filling the gap. you've honestly rescued the ending of book seven for me. and for that, i'm grateful. not that this a regular story, but are you going to keep filling in the space between the end and epilogue?
  

• Epilogue Minus 15

  (#) captuniv 2009-05-20

  Ooh, nicely done. Can't wait to see what the Goblins reactions to Harry having summoned Godric's Blade again are going to be. Wonder who is behind the attacks by the Dementors? Keep up the great work and keep it coming!

• Epilogue Minus 15

  (#) grossclout 2011-01-22

  This 'epilogue' was entertaining, but really seemed to be 'incomplete', unlike the -19 epilogue. I would have really liked to see the resolution of the Dementor problem. Keep up the good work.

• Epilogue Minus 15

  (#) NobleK 2013-09-01

  O.K, what exactly are they working on?! I'm completely confused.....

Sign up to review this story.