Categories > Books > Harry Potter > My Immortal: The Great MSTing
Reviews
My Immortal: The Great MSTing
(#) thegirlwhowasonfire 2011-12-30
I really like your MSTing. In fact, I like it so much that I created an account just so I could tell you to keep going.My Immortal: The Great MSTing
(#) MCRHater 2011-12-30
Oh I'm sorry. If I knew I was dealing with a complete Fretard I'd have used smaller words.
1. MSTing isn't fanfiction.
2. Your MSTing isn't Harry Potter fanfiction
3. You posted this crap in the Harry Potter fanfiction section anyway.
4. Harry Potter fans want to read Harry Potter fanfiction. They don't want to see your bandfic inspired illiterate vomit that only you and your bandfic groupies have any interest in.
5. Why the hell are you surprised that people hate you? Are you truly that stupid?
I think you came into our section deliberately causing trouble. You found it.
I suggest you remove your story from this section and post it where you will find an appreciative audience that wants to read it. No HP fan wants to
My Immortal: The Great MSTing
(#) MCRHater 2011-12-30
(And no, nobody wanted to read My Immortal either)
My Immortal: The Great MSTing
(#) Korisovra 2011-12-31
Ignore the rude asshole, (who just this once actually isn't me) and continue. As much as I hated My Immortal, I do find your commentary semi-amusing.
And anything that mocks the trainwreck that is My Immortal is a definite bonus.
Personally, I hope Enoby offed herself as harsh as that may sound.My Immortal: The Great MSTing
(#) michae1ange1o 2012-01-01
Ok am I missing something here? whats My Chemical Romance got to do with Mystery Science Theater? as far as I know MCR is an emo goth bunch of rubbish and MST is basicaly a group of guys pointing out plot holes and stupid lines in movies.My Immortal: The Great MSTing
(#) MCRHater 2012-01-02
You got it on one michae1ange1o!
Neither MCR or MST have anything to do with each other, or with HP fanfiction.
My Immortal is regarded as the worst ever HP fanfic for a reason, so regurgating bits of it along with useless commentary that only a bandfic junkie would be interested in is not fanfiction.
Most sites don't even allow MSTing. Why? Because it isn't fanfiction & it isn't a story!
Why don't you start up a livejournal or yahoo group for that sort of thing. Hell, you could post this crap in a blog, or find some #emo IRC channel where you can have fun with like-minded people. Nobody is going to bother you there, and you won't be bothering us.
But posting it here is like you're crashing our party, spilling beer on our carpet, knocking over the bins and generally making a mess. Is that what you really want to do?
If you were honest with yourself, you'd realise that the only people rating your MSTing up are those that have followed you along from your usual haunts. The fact that it keeps getting rated back down is because the HP community doesn't want it.
Why don't you leave us to our HP fanfiction, in our HP fanfic area, and you go back to posting your MSTing in MCR or whatever area is yours, and then everyone's happy.
My Immortal: The Great MSTing
(#) michae1ange1o 2012-01-02
Ahhh! ok I getcha. So it should be posted under Mystery Science Theater?My Immortal: The Great MSTing
(#) MCRHater 2012-01-02
Probably, but since I've never spent any time reading outside the HP section I really couldn't say. I'd certainly recommend that the title be renamed to something like; 'My Immortal - a Harry Potter fanfic MSTing' so they know what they're getting.
It's always better to spend some time getting to know a section before you start posting - that's the basic rule of all forums and groups I've ever seen as well - and when that doesn't happen... Well, it isn't pretty is it?
Sign up to review this story.